A supplier stops shipping and points to a clause no one has read since the contract was signed. A co-owner begins steering customers toward a new company with his name on it. A buyer withholds the final payment on an acquisition and claims the financial statements were wrong. Business disputes rarely begin with a lawsuit. They begin with a missed payment, a notice letter, or an email that reads differently the second time through.
The weeks between that first sign and a filed complaint shape a commercial case more than people expect. Decisions made in that window about records, communications, and the contract itself often determine where the dispute will be heard, what evidence will exist, and how much leverage each side carries into the negotiation.
This post covers what commercial litigation involves in South Carolina, the early signs that a dispute is heading toward court, and the practical steps business owners and their advisors should consider before it arrives there.
What Is Commercial Litigation?
Commercial litigation is litigation that arises from business relationships. It includes disputes between companies, between a company and its customers or vendors, and between the people who own and manage a business. In South Carolina these cases are generally heard in circuit court, some belong in federal court, and many commercial contracts send disputes to arbitration instead.
The categories that come up again and again include breach of contract, disagreements among the owners of closely held companies, claims that an officer, manager, or partner breached a fiduciary duty, interference with contracts or business relationships, and disputes arising out of the purchase or sale of a business. When business funds have been diverted by someone entrusted with them, the claim often overlaps with the fiduciary duty and misappropriation issues covered in an earlier post on our site.
What Are the Early Signs a Business Dispute Is Headed to Litigation?
Some signs are formal. A demand letter arrives, or a notice of default or termination under the contract, or a letter asking the business to preserve its documents. Others are behavioral. A counterpart who used to pick up the phone begins communicating only in writing. Outside counsel starts appearing on the copy line. Payments are withheld with an explanation attached, and the explanation reads as though it was drafted carefully. In a dispute between owners, access to the books or the bank accounts suddenly becomes difficult.
None of this makes a lawsuit certain. Each of these signs is, however, a reason to stop treating the matter as an ordinary business disagreement and begin treating it as a potential case.
What Should a Business Preserve Once a Dispute Is Likely?
Once litigation is reasonably anticipated, a business is generally expected to preserve documents and data relevant to the dispute. Failing to do so can lead to sanctions, and in some cases to an instruction allowing the jury to infer that the missing material would have hurt the party that lost it.
Preservation reaches well beyond the paper file. It includes email, text messages on company and personal phones, messaging platforms such as Slack, Teams, or WhatsApp, accounting data, shared drives, calendars, and earlier drafts of the contract. Automatic deletion settings on the email and messaging accounts of the people involved should be suspended, and devices belonging to departing employees should not be wiped and reissued.
The instinct to organize or tidy files before a lawyer sees them is understandable, and it should be resisted. A file that was reorganized after a dispute arose invites questions about what was taken out of it.
What Should the Contract Be Checked For First?
Before anyone argues the merits, the contract often decides the procedure. The provisions worth reading first are the notice and cure clause, which may require written notice and a chance to fix a breach before termination or suit; the dispute resolution clause, which may require mediation or binding arbitration; the forum selection and choice of law provisions, which govern where the case is heard and under which state’s law; any attorney fee provision; any limitation of liability or damages cap; and any jury waiver.
A business that terminates a contract without following its notice provision can hand the other side a breach claim of its own. A business that files in court when the contract requires arbitration can spend months litigating where to litigate. Both problems are avoidable with an early, careful read of the agreement.
What Are the Common Missteps in the Early Weeks?
The first is the email written in frustration. Business owners tend to be direct by temperament, and a message sent the night a dispute begins often becomes an exhibit in the case that follows. Communications about the dispute are better kept factual and brief, and reviewed before they are sent.
The second is self-help. Locking a co-owner out of accounts, withholding distributions, stopping performance under a contract, or moving customers or assets can feel like protecting the business. Done without advice, each of those steps can create a claim against the business that did not exist the day before.
The third is talking too broadly. Discussing the dispute with customers, employees, or on social media creates witnesses and statements that neither side can control later.
The fourth is signing something to make the problem go away. A quick amendment, a release, or a settlement term sheet negotiated without counsel can give up rights the business did not know it had.
What Happens When the Owners of a Closely Held Business Disagree?
Disputes among the owners of a closely held business are among the hardest commercial cases to resolve. The parties are often family members, old friends, or longtime partners, and the business itself suffers for as long as the disagreement continues. A company owned equally by two people is especially exposed, because when those two disagree on a fundamental question, nothing moves.
The governing documents come first: the operating agreement, partnership agreement, or bylaws, and any agreement among the owners. Many contain buy-sell provisions, deadlock procedures, or valuation formulas that can resolve the dispute without a court deciding the merits. Owners who manage the company may also owe fiduciary duties to the company and, depending on its structure, to one another.
When the documents do not supply an answer, South Carolina law gives courts tools to address serious deadlock or misconduct, which in some circumstances can extend to a court-ordered buyout or dissolution. Those remedies are a last resort. In practice, the leverage in an owner dispute tends to come from understanding them well before anyone asks a court to use them.
Where Do CPAs and Outside Advisors Fit?
Accountants and financial advisors are frequently the first professionals to see a business dispute forming. They notice the distribution that did not match the agreement, the related-party payment that was never disclosed, or the revenue that quietly moved from one entity to another. They also hold much of the financial history a case will depend on.
That position makes the advisor’s early observations valuable, and it makes it important for the advisor not to become the person running the dispute. The advisor’s role is usually to preserve what they have, raise the concern with the client, and help the client find litigation counsel while the facts are still fresh. When the matter moves forward, the advisor’s relationship with the client should come through it intact.
What to Expect When You Reach Out
A commercial matter that comes to Bland Richter begins with the documents: the contract or governing agreements, the key communications, and the financial records that show what happened. From there, the partners look at forum, timing, exposure on both sides, and what a realistic path to resolution looks like, including whether the matter should be litigated at all.
Business owners and referring professionals hear that assessment directly from a partner. These are the lawyers you call when your business is on the line.
About Bland Richter, LLP
Bland Richter, LLP is a boutique litigation firm with offices in Lexington and Charleston. Founding partners Eric Bland and Ronnie Richter have practiced together since 1998, and the firm’s work spans commercial litigation, legal malpractice, medical malpractice, and estate litigation. To learn more, visit our Commercial Litigation page.
